Do Teachers Incur Stricter Judgment For Doctrinal Errors?

Dec 13, 2006 · Posted in Bible, Emails

I get people asking for free copies of my Bible prophecy book for various reasons. When a man with a website asked for one, I suggested I would be willing to give the book in exchange for a link from his site (which costs him nothing). He said no since he was like most Christian sites who are overly worried about sending someone to a site that has any “doctrinal error”. Our correspondence sheds some light on this overly emphasized fear:

Tim,

I have been online for more than seven years and have never linked to someone else’s website, even though many have linked to mine (and I appreciate that). The reason is this: I do not know of any other website that does not have serious doctrinal error contained therein. And, if I found one I would not want to link to it because I would need to constantly monitor it in case false teaching was later added. Even with a disclaimer I would not want to be responsible before the Lord on the Day of Judgment for having a part in someone being led astray by false doctrines.

I have read enough on your website (that has nothing to do with end time prophecy) to know that you have several serious false teachings contained therein. And, of course you teach very serious errors concerning end time prophecy.

Please, just keep your book.

“Let not many of you become teachers, my brethren, knowing that as such we shall incur a stricter judgment” (James 3:1).

In Christ Jesus,

{name withheld}

My reply was as follows:

Doctrinal error is unavoidable without a prophet to interpret the scriptures for us today as they had in the First Century and in kingdom years. Surely you must admit you have doctrinal errors yourself.

Thus, certainly the judgment that James 3:1 is talking about has nothing to do with making an honest error in interpreting the very difficult book called the Bible, that Jesus said was difficult on purpose, quoting Isaiah and using parables to hide the meaning which is working quite effectively on Christians today [judging from how few understand his difficult words].

The judgment on teachers is for the typical sins we all do. But they are held more accountable to do what the bible says because they claim to know it well enough to teach it. I assure you, I walk uprightly and have a very happy wife and family as fruits to show it.

Principle of Accountability

For those who are not familiar with this principle of judgment weighted according to accountability, Jesus taught it in many places, including the parable of the wicked servants:

Luke 12:47-48 (KJV) 47 And that servant, which knew his lord’s will, and prepared not himself, neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes. 48 But he that knew not, and did commit things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes. For unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required: and to whom men have committed much, of him they will ask the more.

If you think it through, James must be referring to this as the reason why teachers will be judged stricter. They know better what God’s will is and are more accountable to do it.

Accountability for Works, not Beliefs

There are good God-loving people often on both sides of every argument. The point is, the Bible is hard to understand as it proclaims itself is by design in both the OT and NT. Therefore, how could a loving God condemn us for misunderstanding what his Bible says and holding a false doctrine or belief? The Christian emphasis on doctrine is a result of all the many warring denominations differentiated only by their doctrines. However, the writing of James tells us it’s not about what doctrines we believe, but about our faith in God and our good works together that we are judged by:

James 2:17-20 (ESV) 17 So also faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead. 18 But someone will say, “You have faith and I have works.” Show me your faith apart from your works, and I will show you my faith by my works. 19 You believe that God is one; you do well. Even the demons believe—and shudder! 20 Do you want to be shown, you foolish person, that faith apart from works is useless?

Hopefully what I present above is clear enough in this short and quick post for the reader to realize doctrinal error or mistaken theological beliefs are not to be feared anywhere near as much as how we act and how we treat others.

If this article blessed you and you want to bless back you may...
(Note: I don't solicit donations, but several people have requested a way to make them.)

7 Comments

More Bible Secrets

What the 46% Who Believe Jesus Will Return in 2014 Don't Know But Should...

An Ipsos poll in 2006 found that 25% of adults believed it was at least "somewhat likely" that "Jesus Christ will return to Earth" in the coming year. Among white evangelical Christian adults, a whopping 46% believed this. Yet eight years later Jesus still has not returned. Want to know why Jesus has not come back as expected in 2007 and still won’t be coming in 2014? Read Featured Article

7 Responses

  1. Dan Bagger Says:

    Who is Daniel 7 referring to when he says “Ancient of Days”?

    Who is Daniel 7 referring to when he says “Most High”?

  2. Tim McHyde Says:

    YHWH God, the father. Compare with Revelation 1:14ff

  3. D. Daniel Says:

    Teaching doctrine is to be done carefully. A full working knowledge of the original languages (Hebrew, Aramaic, & Greek) is a necessity. I do not know who translates the writings in the Bible for you, or if you translate for yourself. The one glaring problem on your websites, is the obvious mistranslation of numerous individual words leading to whole passages from Old & New Testaments that are clearly misleading. This is one of the main reasons that falsehoods get handed down generation to generation. If you would get in touch with Dr. Jack VanImpe at jvimi@jvim.com , his body of work over the last 55 years, would be a great help to you in your teaching of Prophecy in the WORD of GOD. Thank you for your time. Keep up your work and keep up your study of Prophecy through correct translation of the WORD OF GOD.

  4. carolyn Says:

    Hi Tim,

    I’m trying to find out how many times the number 12 is mentioned in the Bible (not including verse numbers, etc)

    I’d appreciate your help.

    Thanks and God bless,

    Carolyn
    cali4664@yahoo.com

  5. Tim McHyde Says:

    Looks like 189 times in the KJV

  6. SisMaryLou Says:

    Why take thought for tomorrow? I agree Brother Tim…Man can not be judged of what he doesn’t know…We can only study to show ourselves approved of MAN…no way is that job ever completed…No matter how we may error in our doctrinal studies… I believe we all are trying to do our best…to understand…Gods Word…and that no one who was of God’s Spirit, truth, and His love would intentionally mislead another man…and yet even our best that we can do or relate is not Good enough is it? For its by GRACE through FAITH are you saved…and that not of yourself…lest any man should boast…We here in this Fleshly relm …we all look through a glass…darkly…none of us KNOW it all YET…lest the spirit shall reveal it…Oh and WHAT of LOVE…my little Children LOVE one another…Why LOVE…BECAUSE LOVE is ALL THERE IS…and WHAT IS LOVE…>>

  7. Richard Ruhling Says:

    Hello,

    I visited your site and noted a text quoted that did not have the context which I think is insightful. The quote was Luke 12:47-48 (KJV) 47 “And that servant, which knew his lord’s will, and prepared not himself, neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes. 48 But he that knew not, and did commit things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes. For unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required.”

    That is the end of a wedding parable (Luke 12:36) that begins in verse 32. Being an obscure wedding parable, I find it offers insight to the other wedding parable and like the 10 virgins in Matt 25:5, we are asleep to the meaning. I would offer a website that I think is insightful, but believe even more basic is the website I listed above, http://www.Rapture4.netfirms.com and would welome any comment before giving a site that provides a synthesis of the wedding parables. Thank you for considering this, and I look forward to any response you have to the views on the rapture, Richard

Leave a Comment

Current day month ye@r *

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Gain Biblical Discernment

Understanding of Bible prophecy blesses you (Rev 1:3) and helps you to discern the news, views and predictions you wonder about (Dan 12:10). In my newsletter, I share rare insights from my ongoing Bible study. As a reader, you will quickly and easily gain discernment and find answers to questions you had given up on or forgotten about.
My promise: No spam, no fluff, unsubscribe easily at anytime, and I'll never share your email. Sign up free now by enter your name and email address and clicking the button.

Name: 
Email:  

Did not find your question answered here?

Try searching the site or your question or article suggestion.